Can my attorney negotiate with the lender and also defend the case in court?

Yes, this is common. Running negotiation and litigation together often gives the strongest leverage, since the lender is restricted from proceeding to sale while a complete loss mitigation application is under review.

What is dual tracking and why does it matter?

Dual tracking is when a servicer moves forward with foreclosure while a homeowner's complete modification application is still pending review, which federal servicing rules generally prohibit. Catching a dual tracking violation can pause or dismiss a foreclosure case.

Is a short sale better than letting the foreclosure go through?

A short sale can reduce credit damage and sometimes avoids a deficiency judgment, depending on the lender's agreement, whereas a completed foreclosure sale and judgment stays on record. Which is better depends on individual finances and the lender's terms.

How long does a loan modification review usually take?

It varies by servicer, but reviews commonly take several weeks to a few months once a complete application is submitted, and incomplete paperwork is a common reason for delay or denial.

Loan modification and short sale negotiation vs. fighting foreclosure in court

Once a foreclosure starts, there are really two different tracks a homeowner can pursue, and they aren't mutually exclusive. One is negotiating directly with the loan servicer for a loss mitigation option: a loan modification, forbearance plan, short sale, or deed in lieu of foreclosure. The other is contesting the foreclosure lawsuit itself in court, raising defenses like improper notice, lack of standing to foreclose, or violations of loss mitigation rules that require the servicer to review a complete application before proceeding.

Negotiation-focused representation tends to move faster and stays out of the courtroom, which suits homeowners who want to either keep the home on new terms or exit it without a judgment on record through a short sale. Litigation-focused defense is slower and more adversarial, but it can buy time, force the lender to prove its case, and create leverage for a better settlement.

Many attorneys run both tracks at once: filing an answer and defenses in the foreclosure case while simultaneously submitting a modification package to the servicer, since South Carolina and federal servicing rules restrict a lender from moving forward with a sale while a complete application is pending review.

What it costs

Negotiation-only work, reviewing and submitting a modification or short sale package, is often billed as a flat fee. Contested litigation involving motions, discovery, and hearings usually costs more and may be billed hourly or as a larger flat fee, since the time commitment depends on how aggressively the lender's attorney fights the defenses raised.

Top 3 by our score

Ranked from our published scoring of public Google reviews for foreclosure defense.

1. STONE LAW FIRM, LLC
5.0★ · 82 reviews

88
2. Jabber & Isaac, PA
4.9★ · 330 reviews

93
3. V.R. Perry Law Firm
4.9★ · 75 reviews

86

Browse all providers

FAQ

Can my attorney negotiate with the lender and also defend the case in court?: Yes, this is common. Running negotiation and litigation together often gives the strongest leverage, since the lender is restricted from proceeding to sale while a complete loss mitigation application is under review.
What is dual tracking and why does it matter?: Dual tracking is when a servicer moves forward with foreclosure while a homeowner's complete modification application is still pending review, which federal servicing rules generally prohibit. Catching a dual tracking violation can pause or dismiss a foreclosure case.
Is a short sale better than letting the foreclosure go through?: A short sale can reduce credit damage and sometimes avoids a deficiency judgment, depending on the lender's agreement, whereas a completed foreclosure sale and judgment stays on record. Which is better depends on individual finances and the lender's terms.
How long does a loan modification review usually take?: It varies by servicer, but reviews commonly take several weeks to a few months once a complete application is submitted, and incomplete paperwork is a common reason for delay or denial.

When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from those referrals, but our rankings and scores follow our published method only and are never influenced by referral fees.